The argument began at 8:17 on Monday morning when Martha walked into Bean & Birch wearing an orange scarf patterned with tiny golden leaves.
It was a beautiful scarf. It was also entirely unnecessary. Outside, Lone Pine was wrapped in warm, humid air that felt more like July than the final morning of August.
Lucy looked up from the espresso machine.
“You do know it’s seventy-two degrees already?”
“Yes,” Martha replied. “But tomorrow is the first day of fall.”
From the coffee gang’s favorite table, Sam lowered his mug.
“No, it isn’t.”
Martha stopped.
She slowly turned toward him.
There are moments when a sensible person realizes that silence is the wisest course. Sam, though otherwise a sensible man, had never been especially gifted at recognizing those moments.
“Fall begins at the equinox,” he continued. “September twenty-second.”
“Fall begins tomorrow,” Martha said. “September first. Meteorological fall.”
“That isn’t real fall.”
“It has the word fall in it.”
“So does ‘fallen soufflé,’” Sam said. “That doesn’t make it a season.”
By then, the entire table had grown quiet. Even Toby had stopped buttering his cinnamon toast.
Maren emerged from the kitchen carrying a tray of scones.
“What are we fighting about?”
“The first day of fall,” said Erica.
“Again?” Maren asked.
Apparently this had happened before.
Martha removed her scarf, folded it carefully, and placed it on the back of her chair. The removal suggested neither surrender nor discomfort. It had the solemnity of a lawyer setting down her briefcase before addressing the jury.
“Meteorological fall begins September first,” she explained. “September, October, November. Three complete months. Neat, orderly and sensible.”
Sam shook his head. “Astronomical fall begins at the equinox, when the sun crosses the celestial equator.”
Martha looked toward the others.
“He rehearsed that.”
“I read,” Sam replied.
“Instructions for power tools do not count.”
Tom raised one hand. “I would like to point out that neither the atmosphere nor the sun has consulted Lone Pine.”
“That is true,” said Liam. “Around here, fall begins whenever someone smells woodsmoke and becomes emotionally attached to a sweater.”
“Or when Maren puts pumpkin muffins in the display case,” Toby added.
Everyone looked toward Maren.
“They’ll be here tomorrow,” she admitted.
Martha sat back triumphantly. “The prosecution rests.”
“The prosecution has a pastry-based case,” Sam said. “That won’t hold up in court.”
“It would in Wisconsin,” said Erica.
Lucy brought a fresh pot of coffee to the table. “Personally, I think fall begins the first morning you step outside and say, ‘Ooh, it’s chilly,’ and then go back in for a jacket.”
“No,” said Tom. “It begins the first day somebody complains about people who like pumpkin spice.”
“I don’t complain about them,” Sam said. “I simply question their judgment.”
“Repeatedly,” Martha noted.
“And at considerable length,” Erica added.
Toby, who had resumed buttering his toast, said, “Maybe we need categories.”
He took a paper napkin and borrowed a pen from Liam.
Across the top, he wrote:
OFFICIAL SIGNS THAT FALL HAS ARRIVED
“First,” he said, “meteorological fall: September first.”
Martha nodded.
“Second, astronomical fall: the equinox.”
Sam nodded.
“Third, culinary fall: pumpkin muffins.”
Maren nodded.
“Fourth,” Lucy said, “wardrobe fall: Martha’s scarf.”
Martha nodded again.
“Fifth,” Tom added, “Wisconsin fall: the day you turn on the furnace in the morning and the air conditioner in the afternoon.”
Everyone nodded at that.
“Sixth,” said Erica, “emotional fall.”
Toby paused with the pen above the napkin.
“What is emotional fall?”
Erica looked through the front window. Across the street, the maples were still mostly green, although one small branch near the top of the oldest tree had begun to turn a muted shade of red.
“It’s when you notice the first changed leaf,” she said, “and something inside you changes with it.”
The table grew quiet.
Not an uncomfortable quiet. Bean & Birch had many kinds of silence, and this was one of its better ones—the silence that came when somebody had said something worth leaving alone for a moment.
Outside, a pickup truck rolled slowly down Main Street. Inside, the coffee grinder whirred, dishes clinked in the kitchen, and a soft jazz piano wandered beneath the ordinary sounds of the café.
Liam rested both hands around his mug.
“I suppose seasons rarely arrive on a single day,” he said. “They send small announcements ahead of themselves. A cool morning. An early sunset. One red leaf. A certain slant of light.”
“A pumpkin muffin,” Toby added.
“Yes,” Liam said gravely. “Even a pumpkin muffin.”
Martha looked at Sam. “So you admit that I’m right?”
“I admit that you are one-third right.”
“Two-thirds.”
“One-third.”
“Three-quarters.”
“That is not how thirds work.”
“It’s meteorological mathematics.”
Lucy returned with the coffeepot and topped off their mugs. She had heard enough of the debate to recognize that it was unlikely to produce a winner.
“Perhaps,” she said, “fall begins whenever you are ready to welcome it.”
Martha considered this.
Sam considered it too.
It was, they both realized, an intolerably reasonable answer.
“But that means everyone could have a different first day of fall,” Sam protested.
“Of course,” Lucy replied. “People have different first days for almost everything that matters.”
She moved around the table, filling one mug after another.
“The first day you feel at home somewhere. The first day a stranger becomes a friend. The first day grief doesn’t accompany you into every room. Those dates aren’t printed on calendars either.”
No one spoke for a moment.
Then Martha reached behind her chair, picked up the orange scarf and draped it around Sam’s shoulders.
“There,” she said. “Now it’s fall.”
Sam stared at her.
The scarf looked surprisingly handsome against his blue flannel shirt, although no one was prepared to tell him that.
Toby studied the napkin again and added one final category:
Bean & Birch fall: 8:43 a.m., August 31. Confirmed by scarf.
Maren divided the last maple-pecan scone into seven uneven pieces and passed them around the table.
Lucy refilled the coffeepot. Sam left the scarf around his shoulders, claiming it was only because removing it would give Martha the satisfaction of believing she had annoyed him.
Outside, the morning remained warm and humid. The maples remained green. Summer had not disappeared, and autumn had not fully arrived.
But around the favorite table, among coffee mugs, crumbs, gentle teasing and old friends, a small season of its own had begun.
It was substantive enough to matter and light enough to carry.
And perhaps that was all anyone really needed from a Monday morning.
* * * * * * * * * * * *
This final morning of August is quiet.
Warm and humid weather has returned, and the air conditioner hums steadily in the wee cottage. Beyond the windows, the morning is still dark. Inside, lamps cast their warm pools of light across familiar rooms.
Beside me, coffee steams in my Leona mug. Its aroma is rich and comforting. The first taste is deeply satisfying—the kind of small pleasure that asks for no explanation or defense. Before long the mug will need refilling, and that thought itself feels reassuring. There will be more coffee. There will be another small beginning.
Yesterday was a difficult day, although nothing particularly difficult happened.
I was lethargic—perhaps even a little depressed. Nothing interested me. I drifted through the hours, napping for a while, reading for a while, and then napping again. Even the thought of doing something felt uncomfortable. The day did not feel tragic or dramatic. It simply felt heavy.
Because that is not normally the way I move through my days, I notice its remnants this morning.
I do not know what caused it. Perhaps it was the end of August and the subtle melancholy that comes with any ending. Perhaps it was the approaching end of summer, even though autumn is my favorite season. Perhaps it was grief for my dear friend who died at the beginning of this summer—grief moving quietly beneath the surface, requiring no anniversary or invitation before making itself known.
Or perhaps yesterday was simply a low day.
Not every feeling arrives with an explanation.
We often believe that if we can name the cause of a feeling, we can manage it, correct it or usher it politely out the door. But the heart is not always so orderly. Some sadness comes without a clear story. Some weariness cannot be solved by making a list or thinking more positively. Sometimes the most honest thing we can say is: Yesterday was hard, and I do not entirely know why.
That honesty is not ingratitude.
It is possible to love one’s life and still have a difficult day. It is possible to recognize our blessings while also recognizing the shadows. Gratitude does not require us to pretend that darkness is light. Rather, it gives us a lamp to carry into the darker places.
And so, this morning, I count my blessings—not to erase yesterday, but to meet today.
There is the wee cottage, warm and softly illuminated against the darkness.
There is the steady hum of the air conditioner, keeping the returning humidity outside.
There is the Leona mug beneath my hand and the coffee within it, fragrant, hot and satisfying.
There are books waiting to be read, music waiting to be heard, friends waiting to be remembered and loved.
There is this quiet hour in which nothing is demanded of me.
There is September waiting just beyond midnight.
Tomorrow, meteorological autumn begins. Astronomical autumn will take its time, arriving with the equinox later in the month. The trees will follow their own calendars. One leaf will redden, then another. The mornings will cool. The light will soften. Sweaters will return, coffee will taste even better, and the wee cottage will settle into the season it seems to love best.
Perhaps we are like that too.
Perhaps our inner seasons do not change because a calendar tells them to. Perhaps hope does not always arrive dramatically. Sometimes it begins with one small sign: getting out of bed, turning on a lamp, brewing coffee, noticing that its aroma is pleasing, realizing that today feels a little lighter than yesterday.
That may not seem like much.
This morning, it feels like enough.
I can say goodbye to August with gratitude for all that it held—the beautiful and the difficult, the laughter and the grief, the abundant light and the shadowed afternoons. I do not have to decide that every day was good. I need only recognize that every day was part of the season, part of the journey, part of this life I remain grateful to be living.
Soon I will refill my mug.
Soon the darkness beyond the windows will soften into morning.
Soon August will give way to September, summer will begin its slow surrender to autumn, and the world will move forward—not hurriedly, not all at once, but one changed leaf at a time.
And so starts this day.
Not with every shadow banished, but with a warm light shining among them.
Not with all sadness explained, but with gratitude beside it.
Not with a grand declaration of hope, but with a steaming mug, a beloved cottage, the promise of autumn—and the quiet realization that this life, even on its heavier days, remains worth carrying tenderly forward.
~Wylddane
RSS Feed